A now-viral list of slang that is banned in one teacher's classroom is sparking a debate online, with many users calling out the racist undertones of the list.
X user @hearts4zaniyahh posted the list with the caption:
"How yall feel bout this?"
The list of prohibited words and phrases begins with a paragraph explaining the rationale behind the new mandate as well the consequences for any infractions.
The list, with the heading "These words/sayings are prohibited in my classroom!" begins by first warning:
"If you are caught using these words, you will write a short essay explaining why you chose to use these words in an academic setting to express yourself. There are many ways to articulate what you need to say without using slang."
"Please know that using slang in an academic setting can diminish your capability to become a successful writer. More often than not, the way you speak is the way you will write."
The introduction continued:
"The gibberish some of you choose to use is improper English and sometimes inappropriate for an academic setting."
"This is an educational institution, and you will carry yourself as scholars in my classroom!"
@hearts4zaniyahh/X
The list is comprised of 32 words and/or phrases ranging from "Bruh" to "Bet!" to "It's giving." It also ends with some asterisks denoting the list is "subject to change."
You can see it in its entirety below.
@hearts4zaniyahh/X
Some viewers of the list felt the teacher was just "doing her job."
@AH_Belonging @hearts4zaniyahh She\xe2\x80\x99s a teacher. She\xe2\x80\x99s valuing education. She doesn\xe2\x80\x99t have to learn about her students beyond whatever they need to LEARN/what she needs to be able to teach them.— (@)
Others, however, argued the teacher "doesn't value the language of her students," with many adding that the list seems "anti-Black."
@AxelM66 @AH_Belonging @hearts4zaniyahh This isn\xe2\x80\x99t education, this is enforcing conformity. Writing is mean to be expressive and diverse, even within educational settings. And teachers have a responsibility to learn about their students and build relationship with them, this is fundamental to learning.— (@)
@AH_Belonging @smoke_nd_pearlz @hearts4zaniyahh Interesting she chose specific cultural slang to target & didn\xe2\x80\x99t just say \xe2\x80\x9cno slang\xe2\x80\x9d. If it were just about her wanting them to use professional language, she would prohibit all slang. I\xe2\x80\x99d be awful because I would correct her & anyone else who didn\xe2\x80\x99t speak the Kings English in\xe2\x80\xa6— (@)
A few also expressed there are other more constructive ways to implement "proper English" in student writing.
@khyla_ed @hearts4zaniyahh As a former English teacher, I taught students to translate African American English to \xe2\x80\x9cStandard\xe2\x80\x9d American English rather than punish them for their home language. \n\nWhen you tell students that their language is wrong, you tell them that their cultures & identities are wrong.— (@)
@hearts4zaniyahh I get where they're trying to go with that but I don't agree with cutting out slang. Language is always evolving and there's more than one way to speak English. This just seems like power tripping and respectability politics to me \xf0\x9f\x98\x90— (@)
At the time of writing, the tweet has been quoted and reposted more than 10,000 times and has acquired more than 4,000 comments on the original post, and it doesn't seem like the debate will settled anytime soon.
We would love to know where you stand on this.