Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

The Trumps Were Just Ordered To Testify in New York. That’s Really Good, Right? Let’s Unpack.

The Trumps Were Just Ordered To Testify in New York. That’s Really Good, Right? Let’s Unpack.
Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images // JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images
Make us preferred on Google

New York State Attorney General Letitia James scored a victory in court yesterday after Judge Arthur Engoron ruled that Donald Trump and his two offspring, Don Trump, Jr. and Ivanka Trump, will be required to sit for testimony as part of James’s civil investigation into fraudulently submitted valuations on Trump real estate properties. While the Trumps sought to portray the entire case as an illegitimate political “witch hunt,” the judge dismissed that argument and ordered the testimony to proceed within 21 days and for responsive documents to be produced within 14.

The Trumps tried to focus attention on campaign statements made by James in which she promised to go after Donald Trump, with the clear implication that she was abusing her powers in pursuing a partisan investigation. But these missives seemed directed more at the press and the former president’s base than at the court. (Trump’s attorney, Alina Habba, apparently made “Twitter-style” arguments in court and was disrespectful to the judge, all while arguing that Trump was a “special class” of person who belongs to a protected class. The judge, confused, asked repeatedly which class that was.) In the end, the court paid little heed to the arguments around James’s alleged bias. “Attorney General James, just like respondent Donald J. Trump, was not deprived of her First Amendment rights to free speech when she was a politician running for a public office with investigatory powers,” the decision said.


The Trumps did raise a legal argument that will certainly be the subject of an appeal and which might arguably have some merit, or at least is not yet settled law in the state. By pursuing a civil investigation at the same time that she is openly cooperating with the Manhattan District Attorney on a pending criminal matter, James was seeking an end run around the protections that normally attach to witnesses asked to testify, the Trumps argued. Specifically, in a grand jury criminal setting in New York state, testifying witnesses are granted immunity from prosecution over the subject matter of their testimony. No such immunity exists for witnesses testifying in a civil investigation, however, and therefore the Trumps argued that AG James was getting the benefit of civil rules for what is essentially a criminal case with which her office is presumably sharing information.

The judge dismissed this argument as well, saying it “completely misses the mark.” He noted that the Trumps had not been subpoenaed to appear before a grand jury, so the hypothetical “end run” around grand jury immunity was a wholly academic one. He further ruled that James’s office had uncovered evidence that entitled her to question the Trump family. “In the final analysis,” Engoron wrote, “a State Attorney General commences investigating a business entity, uncovers copious evidence of possible financial fraud, and wants to question, under oath, several of the entities’ principals, including its namesake. She has the clear right to do so.”

That evidence was part of the reason Trump’s longtime accountants at Mazars quit their client in an explosive letter delivered earlier this month and produced in support of James’s motion to compel the Trumps’ testimony. In that letter, the accounting firm walked back ten years of financial statements and cautioned the Trump Organization and its lenders not to rely upon them. When the Trumps sought to portray this damning development in a positive way because Mazars had not “as a whole” found material discrepancies between the information the Trump Organization provided and the actual value of Mr. Trump’s assets, Judge Engoron shot this down quickly, calling the Mazars letter a “red-flag warning” and observing that the argument the letter somehow exonerated the Trumps “is as audacious as it is preposterous.”

While the Trumps are certain to appeal the ruling, their chances of quashing the subpoenas outright are quite low. Come time to testify, it is probable that they will do as Eric Trump did in his deposition, namely to plead the Fifth Amendment some 500 times in response to all or nearly all the questions. But there is a twist here: Because this is a civil investigation for tax fraud and not a criminal matter, a jury that might be later seated in a civil case would be permitted to draw adverse inferences from a witness’s refusal to testify. That could lead to a disastrous verdict against the Trump Organization, which faces the prospect of having its entire charter to do business canceled by the state. Moreover, Donald Trump pleading the Fifth would make headlines all across the world and taint him politically, even if it could not be used adversely against him in a criminal matter.

The former president is not helping his own plight by releasing screeds and howlers at every opportunity. In his court filing on Monday, in an attempt to avoid testifying, Trump declared under oath that he “denies knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth” about his company's finances. Yet in a statement a day later, made after news got out of him being dumped by his accountants at Mazars, Trump spoke glowingly about his company’s “fantastic assets” declaring, “My company has among the best real estate and other assets anywhere in the world, has significant amounts of cash, and has relatively very little debt, which is totally current." He even attempted, no doubt for the benefit of his lenders who might now call in the loans over fraud, to demonstrate by clumsy calculation that the company had a net worth of some 5.7 billion dollars (likely untrue).

James’s office took note of this glaring discrepancy in its responsive pleadings. “It is not unusual for parties to a legal proceeding to disagree about the facts,” the AG’s office wrote. “But it is truly rare for a party to publicly disagree with statements submitted by his own attorneys in a signed pleading — let alone one day after the pleading was filed. That is what Mr. Trump has done here.”

For more political analysis, subscribe to the Status Kuo newsletter.

More from People/donald-trump

Jake Lang making a fool of himself at a cat adoption event.
@JakeLang/X

Far-Right Activist Dragged After Crashing What He Thought Was A 'Furry' Convention That Was Actually For Cat Owners

Far-right lunatic and grifter Jake Lang is once again the laughingstock of the internet for seemingly confusing cat owners with furries.

Like many right-wingers, Lang, who received a pardon from Donald Trump for his role in the January 6 coup attempt at the Capitol, has made a career out of being a deranged provocateur online.

Keep ReadingShow less
screenshot from C-SPAN
C-SPAN

Trump Dragged Over His Desperation After Calling Into C-SPAN Show—And Even The Host Is Caught Off Guard

During the premiere episode of C-SPAN's Washington Journal Primetime, viewers were stunned to hear MAGA Republican President Trump calling in to speak with surprised looking host Mimi Georges.

Trump answered some questions off the cuff about his immigration policies and his Iran War. As usual, he embellished the truth to flatter himself and denied any wrongdoing.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pete Hegseth; Donald Trump
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images; Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images

Pete Hegseth Just Claimed His Controversial Military Operations Were All 'Ordered' By Trump—And Everyone's Making The Same Point

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was criticized for saying that military operations in Iran and Venezuela were "ordered" by President Donald Trump while responding to articles of impeachment brought against him by Republican Representative Thomas Massie.

The impeachment resolution brought by Massie alleges that Hegseth abused his office in several ways, including launching military action against Iran without congressional approval, failing to safeguard civilians, and overseeing deadly strikes on suspected drug-trafficking vessels in the Caribbean.

Keep ReadingShow less
Abdul El-Sayed; Peggy Flanagan; James Talarico
Finn Gomez/Getty Images (left and right); Nathan Posner/Anadolu via Getty Images (center)

The Incoming Freshman Democratic Senators Posed For Their First Selfie At Orientation—And It's Honestly Everything

Social media users can't get enough of the first group selfie featuring incoming freshmen Democratic U.S. Senators, including Abdul El-Sayed and James Talarico.

Last week, Democrats swept midterm election races to win back both the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate in a clear repudiation of the Trump administration.

Keep ReadingShow less
Lori Huang and Jensen Huang attend the 12th Breakthrough Prize Ceremony at Barker Hangar.
Taylor Hill/FilmMagic

Tech Billionaire Apologizes To Wife Of 40 Years After Affair With Alleged Chinese Spy: 'I Am Deeply Sorry'

Most cheating scandals end with awkward family dinners and a whole lot of explaining. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's comes with allegations involving Chinese intelligence and questions about American national security.

And somewhere in that mess is Lori Huang, his wife of more than 40 years, who just received a very public apology.

Keep ReadingShow less