Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Gorsuch Sides With Liberal Justices To Rip Majority's 'Embarrassing' Ruling About Crimes On Indigenous Lands

Gorsuch Sides With Liberal Justices To Rip Majority's 'Embarrassing' Ruling About Crimes On Indigenous Lands
National Archives; Andrew Harnik - Pool/Getty Images
Make us preferred on Google

On Wednesday, the United States Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that states have jurisdiction concurrent with the federal government to prosecute crimes committed by non-Indigenous peoples against Indigenous peoples on tribal lands.

The decision led by the court's conservative theocratic majority is being cited as a clear attack on tribal sovereignty.




One critic of the decision was usually conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch.

Controversial Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote the majority opinion joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Amy Coney Barrett.

Gorsuch joined the minority opinion with the court's three liberal Justices—Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan, and Sonia Sotomayor.

Gorsuch wrote:

"Today the Court rules for Oklahoma."
"In doing so, the Court announces that, when it comes to crimes by non-Indians against tribal members within tribal reservations, Oklahoma may 'exercise jurisdiction'. Ante, at 4."
"But this declaration comes as if by oracle, without any sense of the history recounted above and unattached to any colorable legal authority. Truly, a more ahistorical and mistaken statement of Indian law would be hard to fathom."

He added:

"Tribes are not private organizations within state boundaries."
"Their reservations are not glorified private campgrounds."
"Tribes are sovereigns."
"And the preemption rule applicable to them is exactly the opposite of the normal rule. Tribal sovereignty means that the criminal laws of the States 'can have no force' on tribal members within tribal bounds unless and until Congress clearly ordains otherwise."

The Native American Rights Fund (NARF) and the National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) issued a joint statement on the ruling.

In a press release, they wrote:

"Today, the U.S. Supreme Court, in a 5-4 decision, overturned the long-held understanding that states do not have authority to prosecute non-Indians who commit crimes against Indians in Indian country."
"The Court, in Castro-Huerta v. Oklahoma, held that 'the Federal Government and the State have concurrent jurisdiction to prosecute crimes committed by non-Indians against Indians in Indian country', which strikes against tribal sovereignty and jurisdiction to protect tribal citizens."
"The consequences of the decision–for Tribal Nations, the federal government, and states–will take time to unravel."

NCAI President Fawn Sharp stated:

"The Supreme Court’s decision today is an attack on tribal sovereignty and the hard-fought progress of our ancestors to exercise our inherent sovereignty over our own territories."
"It was only a few months ago that Congress loudly supported tribal sovereignty and tribal criminal jurisdiction with the passage of the Violence Against Women’s Act, reaffirming the right of Tribal Nations to protect their own people and communities, but make no mistake, today, the Supreme Court has dealt a massive blow to tribal sovereignty and Congress must, again, respond.”

NARF Executive Director John Echohawk said:

"Unauthorized and unconsented intrusions on tribal sovereignty are antithetical to tribal sovereignty and tribal treaty rights."




Gorsuch further stated:

"In the end, the Court cannot fault our predecessors for today’s decision. The blame belongs only with this Court here and now."
"Standing before us is a mountain of statutes and precedents making plain that Oklahoma possesses no authority to prosecute crimes against tribal members on tribal reservations until it amends its laws and wins tribal consent."
"This Court may choose to ignore Congress’s statutes and the Nation’s treaties, but it has no power to negate them."
"The Court may choose to disregard our precedents, but it does not purport to overrule a single one."
"As a result, today’s decision surely marks an embarrassing new entry into the anticanon of Indian law. But its mistakes need not—and should not—be repeated."

While on the surface, allowing local and state jurisdiction on tribal lands seems beneficial in prosecuting criminals, Kavanaugh's opinion effectively rules tribal lands are part of any state whose borders they fall within.

But tribal lands are held by sovereign nations through treaties with the United States government and most often predate the creation of the individual states. They also cross state and international borders.

Treaties with tribal nations should be honored in the same way as any other treaty the USA signed with another sovereign nation, such as Canada, Germany or Japan.

South Dakota Republican Governor Kristi Noem tried to force Indigenous nations within her state borders to ignore pandemic protocols, threatening to call out law enforcement or the National Guard.

A ruling such as Kavanaugh's gives credence to Noem's overreach.

More from News

Jensen Huang
Soeren Stache/picture alliance via Getty Images

People Are Debating Whether They Could Be Seduced By A Spy—And Their Hot Takes Are Hilariously On Point

Could you ever be seduced by a spy?

That's the question many are asking after the latest bonkers thing to hit the news: that ousted Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang had an affair with a Chinese spy—ALLEGEDLY.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tom Carney; Ron DeSantis
Mayor Tom Carney/Facebook; Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images for SiriusXM

Florida Mayor Rages After St. Patrick's Day Parade Is Canceled Thanks To DeSantis' Anti-'DEI' Law

In April of 2026, Florida MAGA Republican Governor Ron DeSantis signed the GOP authored and backed SB 1134 to take effect in January of 2027.

Dubbed the anti-DEI law, it bans Florida counties and municipalities from "funding, promoting, or taking official action" related to diversity, equity, and inclusion, which the law defines as: "with reference to race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation."

Keep ReadingShow less
Shakira; Abdul El-Sayed
Michael Loccisano/Getty Images; Finn Gomez/Getty Images

Shakira Just Responded To Abdul El-Sayed's Quip About 'Shakira Law'—And Fans Are Obsessed

Pop star Shakira had social media users cackling after finally responding to then-Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed's joke about Michiganders who fear "Shakira Law" back in October.

El-Sayed was able to fend off Islamophobic attacks against him over many months, actions that culminated in his historic defeat of Michigan Republican Mike Rogers in the state's U.S. Senate race. He repeatedly faced accusations that he is a member of the Muslim Brotherhood and wants to impose Sharia law nationwide.

Keep ReadingShow less
Gerrymandered North Carolina map
Win McNamee/Getty Images

North Carolina Is Now The Textbook Definition Of A 'Dummymander' After Their Gerrymandering Efforts Backfired Massively

North Carolina Republicans are making waves on Wikipedia after the site used them as a prime example of "dummymandering" now that Democrats made historic wins in last week's midterm elections.

Before the elections, Republicans held 10 of the state's 14 U.S. House seats. However, Democrats have now flipped most of those despite the GOP's decision to redraw congressional districts in an attempt to hold onto more seats.

Keep ReadingShow less
Andrew Rannells attends the Television Academy's Inaugural Televerse Festival in Los Angeles.
Chris Delmas / AFP via Getty Images

Andrew Rannells Calls Out Theatergoer Who Chastized Him For Not Showing Up At Stage Door After Broadway Show

For Broadway fans, the final curtain call doesn't always mean the night's over. There's still the stage door, where a little patience and a Sharpie might score an autograph, a selfie, or a few unforgettable seconds with an iconic performer.

Of course, some theatergoers seem to have confused a Broadway ticket with an all-access backstage pass.

Keep ReadingShow less