Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

GOP State Rep. Sparks Outrage After Saying Death Of A Child From Abuse Is 'Benefit To Society'

David Eastman; screenshot of Alaska state House Judiciary hearing
Alaska Legislature

Alaskan State Rep. David Eastman, a pro-Trump Republican with ties to the Oath Keepers, ignited a firestorm after saying it's a financial 'benefit to society' when a child dies of abuse.

Alaskan State Representative David Eastman is facing extreme backlash after he questioned whether his state would benefit from victims of child abuse dying during a House Judiciary Committee hearing on adverse childhood experiences.

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs), according to the CDC, can include experiencing or witnessing violence, abuse, neglect and other traumatic experiences.


Documents distributed to lawmakers during the hearing contained an estimate that, when a child dies because of abuse, it can cost their family and society at large $1.5 million because they aren't given the chance to grow up and join the workforce.

Eastman apparently took issue with this estimate.

He responded by commenting he had heard it argued children dying because of abuse actually economically benefit a society.

"It can be argued, periodically, that it’s actually a cost savings because that child is not going to need any of those government services that they might otherwise be entitled to receive and need based on growing up in this type of environment."

You can see an excerpt from the hearing here:

His colleagues reacted immediately with extreme disapproval.

Some like Democratic Representative Cliff Groh said they were "disturbed" by Eastman's comment.

Democratic Representative Andrew Gray later told his colleagues he and his husband adopted their child through the foster care system and their child had multiple ACEs before coming to live with the couple.

While Gray recognized it might not have been intended that way, but said Eastman's comment came across as though he was implying their child would have been better off dead.

Gray said:

"I would just say for me personally, my child is the greatest joy I’ve ever had—that there is no price tag on that."

House Judiciary Chair Republican Representative Sarah Vance thanked Gray for sharing his story, but neither she nor her GOP colleague Eastman apologized for the statement which led Gray to feel the need to share in the first place.


Eastman has since claimed he was trying to point out the ridiculousness of the argument and compare it to arguments for abortion rights, but his fellow lawmakers apparently didn't follow his thought process.

He further excused himself by blaming the organization presenting during the hearing—Alaska Children’s Trust.

"You have a group that’s come to the Legislature and argued that it’s in the best interest of society and the public and the state to prevent unwanted pregnancies … And now they come on Monday, and the same organization is arguing that, again, they want funding to prevent the very child abuse that they are empowered and focused on preventing."
"If we are to honor that request, then why is it that they are also asking for us to spend money to end the lives of the very children that they’re seeking to protect?"

Vance, who is opposed to abortion herself, later said she believed Eastman was trying to make an anti-abortion argument—claiming many people think of abortion as child abuse.

The Alaska State House later voted 35-1 to censure Eastman for his comments, with the only opposing vote coming from Eastman, marking the 3rd time he has been reprimanded for his behavior in the house.

Those reprimands even included a House subcommittee finding Eastman violated the state's Legislative Ethics Act.

Censure doesn't really carry any concrete consequences, though, and some Alaskans have spoken out saying the measure isn't enough.

Former Representative Colleen Sullivan-Leonard, also a Republican, reacted to the news the House had moved to censure Eastman by tweeting:

"Censuring does nothing to discipline Eastman, or any other elected official."


Given Eastman has been censured twice before and people continue to vote for him, it seems unlikely this latest incident will have much effect on his ability to hold office.

More from News

Sabre; Nancy Mace
@bottleneckloser/Instagram, Jemal Countess/Getty Images for Congressional Integrity Project

Trans Influencer Speaks Out After She's Randomly Targeted By Nancy Mace Online

A trans influencer fired back at MAGA Representative Nancy Mace of South Carolina for mocking her about her trans identity on social media and subsequently making her vulnerable to attacks.

Sabre, whose Instagram handle is @bottleneckloser, posted a video stating that the lawmaker "bullied" her recently for being "hot on Twitter.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Elon Musk
Terence Lewis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

YouTube Becomes Unlikely Hero After Play Button Is Perfectly Placed Over Musk's Face

Call it kismet or divine intervention, but sometimes the fates align to inadvertently create something wonderful.

Or hilarious.

Keep ReadingShow less
Elon Musk and Jim Jordan
Terence Lewis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

GOP Account Hit With Blunt Reminder After Shaming Dems For Celebrating Tesla's Downfall

Minnesota Democratic Governor and former vice presidential candidate Tim Walz joined many Americans in a bit of schadenfreude regarding White House advisor Elon Musk’s recent reversal of fortune.

Musk, the self-described leader of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), has seen protests against his actions on behalf of Republican President Donald Trump. Part of those protests include Tesla owners getting rid of their vehicles, buyers boycotting the brand, and stockholders dumping their shares.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rachel Zegler
Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/FilmMagic/GettyImages

Rachel Zegler Claims 'White Executives' Questioned Her Latina Heritage During 'West Side Story' Casting

Actor Rachel Zegler claimed that skeptical producers questioned her Latina heritage during the casting process for the 2021 West Side Story remake directed by Steven Spielberg.

In the remake of the classic 1961 film adaptation, Zegler starred opposite Ansel Elgort as the star-crossed lovers, Maria and Tony.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Trump Hilariously Melts Down Over Awful Portrait Of Him Hanging In CO State Capitol—And People Can't Stop Trolling Him

People can't help but troll President Donald Trump after he complained about a truly awful portrait of him hanging in the Colorado State Capitol building.

On Sunday night, Trump lashed out against Colorado Governor Jared Polis for hanging what he called a "purposefully distorted" portrait of him in the Colorado State Capitol building.

Keep ReadingShow less