Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Researchers Discover That All Fragments Of The 'Dead Sea Scrolls' At The Museum Of The Bible Are Forgeries

Researchers Discover That All Fragments Of The 'Dead Sea Scrolls' At The Museum Of The Bible Are Forgeries
GALI TIBBON / Contributor / Getty Images

A recent National Geographic article brought to light some unfortunate findings about the fragments of the Dead Sea Scrolls currently held by The Museum of the Bible: all 16 of them are modern forgeries.


The forged fragments of ancient religious texts were under investigation by researchers hired by the museum itself, and their findings were announced to the world at an academic conference also hosted by the Museum of the Bible.

Museum of the Bible CEO Harry Hargrave explained the museum's position on the findings during the conference.

"The Museum of the Bible is trying to be as transparent as possible. We're victims—we're victims of misrepresentation, we're victims of fraud."

Art fraud investigator Colette Loll covered how the forgeries came to be, and how they fooled the various scholars who had authenticated them.

Loll said that the fragments were likely made using ancient materials, but were painted in recent years to make them look like the real Dead Sea Scrolls.

"These fragments were manipulated with the intent to deceive."

The nearly 100,000 Dead Sea Scrolls fragments that existed and were authenticated before 2002, when the forgeries turned up, are not having their authenticity questioned. Only those which were discovered in 2002 or after are called into question by the team's findings.

Årstein Justnes, a researcher from Norway's University of Agder, pointed out why these 16 fragments being found to be forgeries was so impactful.

"Once one or two of the fragments were fake, you know all of them probably are, because they come from the same sources, and they look basically the same."

Jeffrey Kloha, Museum of the Bible's chief curatorial officer, discussed the museum's reasoning for further research into remaining fragments after the first 5 were evaluated.

"It really was—and still is—an interesting kind of detective story. We really hope this is helpful to other institutions and researchers, because we think this provides a good foundation for looking at other pieces, even if it raises other questions."

This wasn't a minor case of fraud to gain a few dollars, either.

The asking price for artifacts like these is not small.

The Museum of the Bible contracted Loll's company, Art Fraud Insights, to investigate the scroll fragments in their collection in February 2019.

The team of five investigators that she assembled examined the fragments both chemically and physically, and quickly came to the concensus that all 16 of the samples were forgeries.

This decision was partially based on the fact that museum's pieces were made of the wrong materials. Most of the authentic scroll fragments were written on parchment, while the forgeries were on leather.

Microscopic examination also showed that the text on the Scrolls had been recently painted on the already-ancient leather.

The origin story, or lack thereof, of the prices also caused the team to question their authenticity.

Justnes described the issue with their provenance succinctly.

"We should perhaps really hope that [the post-2002 fragments] are fakes ... If they are fakes, we have been duped. But if they are authentic, unprovenanced artifacts, they must have been looted, they must have been smuggled—they were tied to criminal acts in some way."

The authentic scroll fragments can be traced to Palestine's Qumran caves, where indigenous Bedouin herders found the Scrolls in jars in 1947.

All of the pre-2002 fragments can be traced back to one antiquities dealer: Khalil Iskander Shahin, more often known as Kando.

The new fragments were also rumored to be from the Kando family, with some of the fragments in The Museum of the Bible's collection having been purchased directly from Kando's son William.

Though the forged pieces all likely share an origin point, no one knows the identity of the forger.

Many people chimed in on Twitter about the forgeries.

Many pointed out that this isn't all of the Dead Sea Scrolls, just those housed at the museum.





And others emphasized the impact that these findings will have.

While the group's findings don't question the authenticity of the original Dead Sea Scrolls, they do demonstrate how collectors can be fooled by convincing forgeries.

The materials were of approximately the right age, and the forger was apparently very careful, so the fakes fooled many experts until they were examined microscopically and chemically.

The NOVA documentary Dead Sea Scrolls Detectives is available here.

More from Trending

Kid Rock
Todd Kirkland/Getty Images

Kid Rock Dragged After Donning A Truly Over-The-Top Outfit For His White House Visit

Singer Kid Rock was slammed for wearing a loud patriotic costume inside the Oval Office as Republican President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Monday against ticket scalping.

The rocker's outfit consisted of a red, white, and blue jacket emblazoned with two eagles facing each other above the American flag with the number 250, a nod to America's upcoming 250th anniversary, and white stars on his sleeves.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Bill Cassidy
CNBC

MAGA Senator Just Said The Quiet Part Out Loud With Epic Freudian Slip About Medicare

Louisiana Republican Senator Bill Cassidy was widely mocked following his inconvenient slip of the tongue during a CNBC interview as he mused about finding ways to "cut" Medicare before quickly correcting himself.

The exchange occurred after host Rebecca Quick pressed Louisiana Republican and former physician Bill Cassidy on how his party intended to fund the “trillion-dollar tax cuts” sought by President Donald Trump.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Tim Sheehy
CNN

GOP Senator Gets Blunt Reality Check After Comparing Trump Tariff 'Pain' To Home Renovation

Montana Republican Senator Tim Sheehy was criticized after he tried to compare the "short-term pain" of President Donald Trump's tariffs to home renovation, a claim so ridiculous that CNN's Kaitlan Collins quickly pushed back on the analogy.

Trump has repeatedly referred to April 2 as “Liberation Day,” pledging to impose tariffs—taxes on imports—to reduce U.S. reliance on foreign goods. He has framed these tariffs as “reciprocal,” aiming to match the duties other nations place on American exports.

Keep ReadingShow less
Susan Crawford; Elon Musk
Scott Olson/Getty Images (left and right)

Liberal Wisconsin Judge Calls Out Elon Musk In Victory Speech—And It's Everything

Liberal judge Susan Crawford called out billionaire Elon Musk in her victory speech after winning a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, basking in successfully beating her Republican opponent Brad Schimel and ensuring that the nonpartisan court’s narrow 4-3 liberal majority remains intact despite Musk's efforts to sway the race.

Musk fueled the high-stakes race, having poured more than $20 million into supporting Schimel, according to state campaign records. That includes $3 million to the state Republican Party—$2 million of which was donated just last week. Due to state election laws, large contributions must be funneled through political parties before reaching candidates.

Keep ReadingShow less

People Describe The Worst 'Bonus' They've Ever Gotten At Work

Most of us have worked at one problematic workplace, with reasons ranging from toxic coworkers to terrible bosses to unlivable pay. Sometimes, it feels like a joke that the employees are even being paid at all!

But the biggest joke of all might be the end-of-year bonus, or lack thereof. They're at times so laughable, they take the cake for horrible work conditions, or are quite literally, a slice of cake.

Keep ReadingShow less