An Airbnb user was threatened by an agitated apartment host who demanded that they remove their four out of five-star rating or "the fun begins."
While patrons on various service apps are not obligated to leave reviews detailing their experiences, it is a customary practice to let future customers know what to expect–whether the experience was positive or unacceptable on a five-star scale.
Airbnb–the vacation rental service–is one such app in which both the customer and homeowner mutually rate each other in the hopes of earning a polished reputation for repeat business.
Unfortunately, there are times when a less than stellar review can lead to an unsettling outcome as it did for Professor Dr. Alex Moore.
Moore tweeted at Airbnb asking for help in the interest of their and the public's safety.
"Can you explain to me and everyone else why the host who sent me this message is still active on your platform?" they asked, adding, "This person is clearly a threat and should not be allowed to host guests."
\u201cIn the interest of my own personal safety as well as public safety, @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp: Can you explain to me and everyone else why the host who sent me this message is still active on your platform? This person is clearly a threat and should not be allowed to host guests.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
Moore shared a screenshot of the unnerving request from the host, who wrote:
“I have your picture, your name and your number."
“You have 48 hours to remove your review or I’m hiring a private investigator to obtain your address and then the fun begins.”
@Dr_AlexM/Twitter
The host additionally informed Moore they were blocked from responding directly to the number.
Moore said they left a 4/5 review "with a positive message" that allegedly "brought [the host's] average rating down from a 5 to a 4.95" based on the 20-review count from previous renters.
\u201cI have already contacted local authorities, but beyond protecting myself, @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp has an obligation to the public to act. Their listing is still active as of this posting and should be taken down immediately.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
@Dr_AlexM/Twitter
While users were sympathetic to her situation, some offered insight into the consequences of a review that is not a 100% positive rating.
\u201c@Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp To all the people who keep saying they don\u2019t give 100%, there are many industries that penalize you for receiving less than perfect score. I used to sell cars and once had a person tell me that they never give 10/10, I even told them it would hurt me financially and it cost 10%\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
\u201c@Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp The people who ask why leave a 4 star for getting what was expected are part of the problem. 5 star is the best review there is. It need not to be given out as a 'common courtesy'. The difference b/w 4 and 5 is the difference b/w met expectations & exceeds expectations.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
\u201c@vrdn_23 @Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp Yes; I have a friend who's an AirBnb host, and she works very hard to ensure good experiences for her guests, and she freaks out over reviews that are not 5 stars because AirBnb penalizes hosts for that. It sounds like a terrible system and I hope AirBnb fixes it.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
Regardless, receiving less than a 5-star review does not warrant bullying, as many users pointed out.
\u201c@Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp The people who ask why leave a 4 star for getting what was expected are part of the problem. 5 star is the best review there is. It need not to be given out as a 'common courtesy'. The difference b/w 4 and 5 is the difference b/w met expectations & exceeds expectations.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
Former Airbnb customers shared their unpleasant experiences using the service.
\u201c@Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp I stopped using Airbnb\u2019s a long time ago because their poor quality customer service. We found a bat \ud83e\udd87 flying around a bedroom the first time I used them. That was a huge NOPE. The apartment wasn\u2019t as described either, and their response and the host\u2019s response were lackluster.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
\u201c@Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp I literally just had an experience while currently at an @Airbnb \u2014 the host sent me a text to make an adjustment to something I\u2019d just done \u2014 only could\u2019ve happened if they had hidden cameras that I still can\u2019t find.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
\u201c@Dr_AlexM @Airbnb @AirbnbHelp @Airbnb doesn\u2019t care they just care for profit last year a host was asking me about my ethnicity and as soon as I responded Palestinian & he asked me what my political beliefs were & told me I needed to show him my credit score (not allowed) I reported it and Airbnb did NOTHING\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
Moore contacted the police after seeing the listing was still active.
Airbnb apologized for the situation and informed Moore they would be directed to the appropriate department to take action.
When they received a similar response from Airbnb support the next day, Moore advised them to "take meaningful action as soon as possible."
\u201cQuick update: The listing is still posted, but I just spoke with Vancouver PD and they will be sending someone over to tell the host to leave me alone "or else". They may also revoke his license to participate in house-share programs. Fingers crossed.\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
They received hopeful news the next day.
"It’s confirmed that his listing has been taken down!" Moore shared.
"I will continue to follow up with @AirbnbHelp regarding next steps."
"Thank you all again for amplifying this and sharing your stories to help keep others safe. Muting this and restricting comments for my sanity. Stay safe!"
\u201cIt\u2019s confirmed that his listing has been taken down! I will continue to follow up with @AirbnbHelp regarding next steps. Thank you all again for amplifying this and sharing your stories to help keep others safe. Muting this and restricting comments for my sanity. Stay safe!\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
They posted a final update with a screenshot of Airbnb's message indicating the company took proper action.
\u201cFINAL UPDATE:\u201d— Dr. Alex Moore (@Dr. Alex Moore) 1655569217
Moore had one thing left to say after declaring the thread will no longer be updated.
"For anyone traveling to Vancouver and in need of affordable accommodations - avoid this host."
So if you need lodging in Vancouver, it may behoove you to steer clear of this listing based on the host's alleged indiscretion.
And that's doctor's orders.