People Break Down Their Favorite Movies Where The Bad Guy Wins

Man on Fire

"Man on Fire."

- Sapphic_Butterfly

Nightcrawler

"'Nightcrawler,' definitely. Only a few people mentioned it in this thread, which I find surprising. It fits the definition of the 'bad guy winning' perfectly and it is also a really good movie."

- belshezzar

Valkyrie

"'Valkyrie.' Crazy to think that Hollywood didn’t have to embellish much because those events actually happened in real life."

- lawontheside

Unforgiven

"'Unforgiven.'"

"Eastwood's character is the bad guy. He killed women and children and everything that walked or crawled. He was a hired vigilante."

"Little Bill was the law. But he was also a belligerent a-hole who beat a man to death and let another get away with cutting up a woman’s face because she was a w**re. He got what was coming whether he deserved it or not."

- PoorPauly

Starship Troopers

"'Starship Troopers.'"

- B3taWats0n

"It still baffles me that some people don't get that the humans are the bad guys. Neil Patrick Harris becomes more and more Nazified over the course of the movie until he's just wearing an SS uniform in the last scene."

- SergeantChic

"Consider:"

"At no point is there any evidence to the audience (unless presented by a newscast of a fascist regime) that the bugs are the aggressors."

"No fighting takes place on human territory."

"There is no clear cause for the bugs to throw a rock at the earth."

"The bugs did nothing wrong."

- couchsurfingpotato

Infinity War

"'Infinity War.'"

- O5CR

"Serious question for anyone who's seen that movie more recently: did Thanos have a 50% chance of wiping himself out of existence when he did the snap?"

- Discuffalo

"Yes, and this was confirmed by the Russo Brothers in a Q&A as well. That's why he seems surprised and gives a little smirk before teleporting away after the snap; he sees himself being exempted as proof that he was doing the right thing."

- fredagsfisk

"Titan Roulette."

- WayneAndWax

Halloween

"Basically ALL the 'Halloween' movies. Michael wins every single time except for 'Halloween Ends,' which is a real absolute first, to be honest."

"First runner-up: 'The Collector.'"

"Second runner-up: every single 'Saw' movie."

- whitehack

Midsommar

"'Midsommar' if you treat the cult as the bad guy."

- tkdyo

"The cult is definitely the villain of the story."

- A**_a**_in99

X-Men: First Class

"X-men: First Class (2011)."

"'I prefer... Magneto" what follows is the most bada** villain theme since imperial march."

- TeamAlphaSquad

"'I've been at the mercy of men just following orders. NEVER AGAIN.'"

- killingjoke96

"Magneto is the deuteragonist of the film."

"Shaw is the Bad Guy. And he gets a penny for his thoughts (a coin through his head)."

- streakermaximus

Lad Abiding Citizen

"Depending on your perspective, 'Law Abiding Citizen.'"

- lyzaros

"I can’t stand watching that movie. Every time I hope Gerard Butler will win, and Jamie Foxx catches him every d**n time…"

- KidAndrogynous

"Such a bulls**t ending. It's like they passed out of having Gerard Butler's character win, like they couldn't show a man with 10 years of planning pull off his vengeance plan against the justice system in case the audience got ideas."

"It seemed like a case of Jamie Foxx wouldn't allow them to make his character 'lose', but this is a myth apparently. It's still s**t, though."

- vaguebiscuits

"Yeah, it p**ses me off that Butler's character loses."

"The 'good guys' only won because they broke the law. The cop and the lawyer didn't get a warrant, and it was literally shrugged away as they broke into and entered the garage. If they were actually sticking to the rules they espoused, as they should have, Butler's character would have gotten away with it."

"I know, I know... The good guys have to win, Butler's character was a murderous psychopath, ends justify the means, etc. But I think the ending was a copout."

- cstretten

Gone Girl

"'Gone Girl.'"

- solitamaxx

"Well done movie, absolutely hated it and will never watch it again. Made me so d**n mad, but I understand it did exactly what it was meant to."

- Raccoonanity

Skeleton Key

"'Skeleton Key.'"

- nursesarahrn78

"A very interesting movie. The ending... whew!"

- Forsaken_Button_9387

"The scream I scrumpt when she said, 'Baby, you just trapped yourself!'"

- soljjr

Fallen

"'Fallen.' That movie was f**king awesome, great ending."

- TheRealOcsiban

"Did I ever tell you about the time I almost died?"

- crazym108

"Now remember, I told you I was going to tell you the story of the time I ALMOST died."

- whyisreplicainmyname

"Tiii-i-i-ime... is on my side. Yes, it is..."

- AKeeneyedguy

Cabin in the Woods

"'Cabin in the Woods.'"

"Well, the bad guys actually lose, but the world ends as a result."

- Jonny-Max

"It's one of my favorite twists on a horror movie ever."

- careater

"Are they really the bad guys though? Sure, they act like a**holes about killing people, but it’s kind of important that they do it."

- Freedom_7

"The gods they are trying to appease, it’s movie audiences like you and me. We are the actual bad guys."

"If what we expect to see doesn’t happen, like a virgin sacrificial ritual, we will destroy the movie at the box office. That’s the big hand you see at the end."

- Initial_E

"So ... our nostalgia and need for cliches is the bad guy? We're the reason Hollywood only does remakes now?"

"F**k... that's darker than I realized."

- konsf_ksd

Arlington Road

"'Arlington Road.'"

- Dapper_Interest_8914

"This should be top."

"'Infinity War' and 'Empire Strikes Back' are not the ending of the story, and as we know, the bad guy eventually loses."

"This is one of the only movies where the bad guy wins, and that's it, the end. He doesn't die and win like in 'Se7en.' There's no sequel to make right the wrong. The baddies just f**king trick the protagonist big time and win."

"Leaves you feeling almost angry, stunned even."

- 8blackJack8black

Everyone can appreciate a happy ending, but these movies go to show that a movie can still be great without the good guy coming out on top.

In fact, it might even make these movies all the move impactful and memorable.