Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

People Debate Mandatory Retirement At 75 For Congress And The Supreme Court

US Supreme court
white concrete building under white clouds during daytime
Photo by Adam Szuscik on Unsplash

When Ruth Bader Ginsburg passed away in the fall of 2020, the United States panicked.

Namely, democrats and liberals were terrified by the prospect of another conservative judge on the United States Supreme Court, which already had a two-seat majority.

Then of course, there was the ongoing debate as to whether or not then-sitting president Donald Trump was entitled to pick another Supreme Court judge, as the 2020 presidential election was only weeks away.

Barack Obama was famously banned from appointing Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court owing to the fact that it was an election year, even though President Obama still had eight months left in his presidency.

Of course, RBG's death at age 87 also brought to the forefront an ongoing debate about whether there should be age limits for Supreme Court Justices.


Redditor houstontexas2022 was curious to hear where the Reddit community stood on this issue, leading them to ask:
"Would you support a mandatory retirement age of 75 for US House, US Senate & US Supreme Court Justices and if not why?"

If There Are Minimums, There Should Be Maximums

"Yes."

"We have age minimums."

"We need maximum age limits these people are making decisions for a future they won't be involved in."- mattjf22

Age Doesn't Always Equal Wisdom...

"I am 82 years old."

"Personally, I feel that anyone my age who still gets off on power needs to be kept away from normal people."

"But to the point of this post, the world has been run by old people since the beginning of our species, and just look at the place!"

"Yes, if you were intelligent to begin with your wisdom and common sense will increase with age, but so will your cynicism."

"If you were a young jacka**, you will become an old jacka** — and a hide-bound prejudiced old jackass at that."

"Give them a nice pension at 70, with the condition that if they mess with politics or government again they lose the pension."- SemichiSam

Would Have Greatly Affected The Last Two Elections

"70 and as for president no one can run over 65."

"FFS get with the program folks just retire."- Upstairs-Bid6513

Age Limits Are Only The Beginning

"Age requirement of 65, 2 term limit, Congress people serve 4 year instead of 2 year terms, and no campaigning more than 60 days before the election."- Deedoodleday

Term Limits First

"I feel like if we were to attach an age to it, it should be the age of retirement, but I feel like it would be more important to have term limits."

"Limits would fix almost all the same issues and address more, without arbitrarily deciding someone is too old to serve the state."- Askmyrkr

"Term limit is the way to go."- bob2235

Not Where Our Concerns Should Be...

"No, the problem isn't age, it's our election system."

"Politicians get old in office because it's so f*cking hard to vote them out!"

"End legal bribery, end FPTP, and we'll see a much healthier turnover in our political processes."- FountainsOfFluids

What Matters Is Their Qualifications And Abilities

"I'll be the contrarian."

"If you're good, you're good, regardless of age."

"I'll take a 75-year-old who is smarter, savvier, and better representative of my values than a 35-year-old."

"If you don't like them because they're senile, don't vote for them, that's all."

"Honestly, I feel the same about lower-age limits that aren't just the age of majority."- walkerintheworld

75 Is still Too Old...

"I would go even younger at 70."

"Sure that may mean we would lose Bernie, we would also be ditching McConnell, Pelosi, and the other fossils in office who refuse to address the problems we face."- Daryno90

Wrong Priorities

"Would rather see mandatory voting like Australia."- szthesquid

Wouldn't Change Anything

"No."

"Making politicians retire at some arbitrary age would not address the underlying problems our system has."- giope_1995

"What problem are you trying to solve by doing this?"

"Apparently, people want to be represented by ancient dinosaurs."- SideShow117

Defeats The Point Of Democracy

"No, absolutely not."

"Nor should there be a minimum age (apart from 18)."

"The point of a representative democracy is that the people vote for whom they want."

"Putting restrictions on who can run serves no purpose other than invalidating the votes of people you disagree with."

"It's not up to you or me to decide who is 'valid' as a candidate."

"That's the entire point of democracy."

"And to those of you that are convinced that if all the old people were just gone, then everyone would agree with you, you're ironically the exact kind of uninformed voter that you claim to be trying to prevent."- scottevil110

"No, because if there was a 76-year-old candidate I liked I would want the freedom to vote for them."

"Supporting things like this is so short-sighted."- tedesco455

In the heat of the moment, it's easy to make rash decisions about government and democracy.

Frustrating though it may be, it's important to remember progress is a slow, steady stream and doesn't come easily.

Also worth remembering, there are indeed two sides to most arguments, and far more can be resolved in a discussion than in an attack.

More from Trending/best-of-reddit

Alex Cooper singing 'Take Me Out to the Ballgame'
@MBDChicago/Twitter (X)

'Call Her Daddy' Host Alex Cooper Gets Brutally Booed At Wrigley Field After Painfully Off-Key Singing

If there's one thing that all baseball fans can come together about, it's the importance of their traditions—and songs.

In the seventh inning at Wrigley Field during a match between the Cubs and the Cardinals, popular Call Her Daddy podcast host Alex Cooper was invited to sing "Take Me Out to the Ballgame" and brought two backup dancers with her.

Keep ReadingShow less
Linda Yaccarino
Patrick T. Fallon/AFP via Getty Images

X CEO Resigns Day After AI Chatbot Grok Praised Hitler In Alarming Series Of Antisemitic Tweets

Linda Yaccarino—the former NBC Universal executive who later took the reins at X—stepped down as CEO of billionaire Elon Musk's platform after two years on the job just a day after Grok, the platform's AI chatbot, went on antisemitic rants and openly praised Adolf Hitler.

Grok issued deeply antisemitic responses on Tuesday following a reported software update that encouraged the bot to embrace what developers described as the “politically incorrect.” Taking that directive to heart, Grok responded with a series of disturbing posts that included praise for Hitler and even a statement expressing its aspiration to become a “digital version” of the Nazi leader.

Keep ReadingShow less
Black and white photo of a falling spider.
Photo by CHUTTERSNAP on Unsplash

People Divulge Their 'Rare' Phobias That People Refuse To Believe

I am a SEVERE claustrophobic.

I have struggled with this issue for decades.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ted Cruz
Kayla Bartkowski/Getty Images

'The Onion' Rips Ted Cruz With Brutal Headline After Yet Another Vacation During Texas Disaster

The satirical news site The Onion had social media users cackling with its brutal headline mocking Texas Republican Senator Ted Cruz for once again being out of the country when Texas was hit by another deadly natural disaster.

Cruz faced considerable national backlash after he flew to Cancún while millions of people went without food and water as a result of the February 2021 Texas power disaster. At least 246 people were killed directly or indirectly; some estimates suggested as many as 702 people were killed as a result of the crisis.

Keep ReadingShow less
Elon Musk and Grimes
Kevin Tachman/Getty Images for Vogue

Elon Musk's Ex Grimes Calls X Platform A 'Poison' And 'Theatre' After Social Media Hiatus

Claire Boucher—who performs and creates under her stage name Grimes, but prefers her birth name or just "C" offstage—recently returned to her musical persona's social media accounts after taking a hiatus for her own well-being.

Once extremely active, she noted on X in April:

Keep ReadingShow less